Warning: This review/ramble will contain spoilers for all three books.
Where do I even start talking about these books?
(Now, I don’t normally do book reviews, or talk at length about things I’ve read, so if I stumble a bit, please forgive me. I’m refining as I go, and usually writing these over the course of a few days.)
Several years ago, I won’t admit how many, I spotted the cover for the first book in a Barns & Noble somewhere, and I was in a shopping phase so I would browse a store, take a picture of a book, and keep it for later. I’ve tried to add most of those to lists but there is still an entire photos folder on my phone just of books.
The cover caught my eye, as they usually do. I am not a ‘don’t judge a book by it’s cover’ kind of person, I am all about the cover. I liked the look, I liked the uniforms, and I liked the quote. I was intrigued. Fast forward to sometime early last year when they came up on my kindle, I suspect on sale or special offer. Somehow I ended up with all three of them in my kindle, and then I went up to Scotland for a few days and went camping, so no internet, limited phone service, brought my tablet specifically for reading. (I don’t own an actual kindle, never have.)
I read all three books, some 1700+ pages, in under two weeks. I haven’t been so sucked into a set of books in years. That’s not entirely true, I read the first of Brent Weeks’ Shadows trilogy in a day, but that was because I was stuck sitting around with literally nothing to do, couldn’t go anywhere, no access to phone or anything. And I loved those too, but the speed was out of necessity. I do need to read them again because I missed a lot reading that fast.
Anyway. I started Promise of Blood on May 24th, and I finished Autumn Republic on June 2nd. So, 9 days in total. My second read through at the end of the year took about a month all told. Though, that was largely because I would read for 4 hours one day and then not read again for a week. I read one of them in two days, again.
(As a note I have the sequel trilogy, Gods of Blood and Powder, I just haven’t had a long enough span of time to sit down and start, because I know how I’ll get sucked in. They’re sitting on my dresser waiting for my attention.)
What I think I first found so interesting was, of course, the idea of a connection between gunpowder and magic. As a Sagittarius with pyromaniacs tendencies (I once took apart a handful of sparklers, put the resulting powder in a jar and threw in a match ((To be fair that is actually my most interesting moment, and my only story)) and ran. It was awesome) I absolutely love the idea of being able to have an awareness of gunpowder and do things like change the direction of a blast, not to mention just setting it off with your mind. Then of course the story dragged me in.
I don’t often see books where there is truly more than one main character. Usually you have strong supporting characters, but Taniel and Tamas really are both the main character in these books. There is of course the Inspector as well, but for me he is the strong secondary.
The image of the world is fascinating, being built up slowly around all the action. Promise of Blood just dives right in and you find out more about the land and the Nine as you go along. I have to admit, I didn’t like Tamas at first, but by the end of Autumn Republic…there might have been a tear or two.
I love how all the characters interacted, I loved that events jumped ahead by days or weeks but you didn’t feel like you missed anything. In my own writing I’ve always had an issue with time flow and feeling like large jumps are disconcerting and hard to follow, and I’m still trying to learn how to avoid that. I also enjoyed how the events jumped all over the map, but I suspect, having looked at the map, and the more detailed map of the Nine in Sins of Empire, I probably have all the directions and things backwards in my head.
One thing I look for in a book is if it feels -real-. I’m not sure how to go into more detail than that because like art, reality is an abstract concept to each person based on their perception (go away Plato) so that’s the only word I have. But I suppose I mean, I feel like I could step into the world and happily live there. I find that more with history than with fantasy books but there have been several that have caught my attention like that and these books are one of them.
My only disappointment has been that some of the companion stories don’t appear to be available online anymore. I have ready every one I can get my hands on but I know I’m missing at least two, and I hope that someday they resurface somewhere. For now I’m just going to continue enjoying what I’ve got.
To everyone reading, I would like to say thank you for sticking with me to the end of this post and if you haven’t read these books, go look for some more reviews. If I didn’t convince you, someone else just might, and I think they’re very worth being convinced.
Until Next Time
Caitlin